The Myth of Progress

If you have not already read Tom Wessels’ 2006 book [The myth of progress - Towards a sustainable Future], I highly recommend it to you. It makes some core arguments in support of our efforts to support a carbon neutral economy as a response to global warming and biosphere degradation.

Happy New Year,

Jock

Editorial Reviews

Book Description

In this compelling and cogently argued book, Tom Wessels demonstrates how our current path toward progress, based on continual economic expansion and inefficient use of resources, runs absolutely contrary to three foundational scientific laws that govern all complex natural systems. It is a myth, he contends, that progress depends on a growing economy.

Wessels explains his theory with his three Laws of Sustainability: (1) the law of limits to growth, (2) the second law of thermodynamics, which exposes the dangers of increased energy consumption, and (3) the law of self-organization, which results in the marvelous diversity of such highly evolved systems as the human body and complex ecosystems. These laws, scientifically proven to sustain life in its myriad forms, have been cast aside since the eighteenth century, first by western economists, political pragmatists, and governments attracted by the idea of unlimited growth, and more recently by a global economy dominated by large corporations, in which consolidation and oversimplification create large-scale inefficiencies in material and energy usage.

Wessels makes scientific theory readily accessible by offering examples of how the Laws of Sustainability function in the complex systems we can observe in the natural world around us. He shows how systems such as forests can be templates for developing sustainable economic practices that will allow true progress. Demonstrating that all environmental problems have their source in the myth of Progress’s disregard for the Laws of Sustainability, he concludes with an impassioned argument for cultural change.

About the Author

TOM WESSELS is a professor of ecology and the founding director of the Master’s degree program in Conservation Biology at Antioch New England Graduate School. His books include Untamed Vermont (Thistle Hill Publications, distributed by UPNE, 2003), The Granite Landscape: A Natural history of America’s Mountain Domes from Acadia to Yosemite (2001), and Reading the Forested Landscape: A Natural history of New England (1997).

-- JockGill

JockGill Says:

You can read Tom Wessels’ book “The myth of Progress” as a new critique of Unregulated Free Market Capitalism that is neither Marxist, Communist nor Leninist. That is to say the complex systems science critique is a new entrant in the field that is NOT from the traditional FDR wing of the old and exhausted Left.

In essence Wessels, whether he knows it or not, is urging the development of a view more akin to the pre-Industrial capitalism of Adam Smith [1776] and Ben Franklin’s Junto club formed in 1727, or 49 years before the Wealth of Nations was published. No wonder Franklin found Smith’s work congenial. Smith was opposed to concentrations of capital and remote ownership, both of which I suspect would have been opposed by the Junto as well.

The Junto was a club established in 1727 by Benjamin Franklin for mutual improvement. The first of Franklin’s projects for social improvement by collective effort in Philadelphia was the Junto, or Leather Apron club, organized in 1727 to debate questions of morals, politics, and natural philosophy and to exchange Knowledge of business affairs. Ben Franklin was a gregarious person, who loved sitting down and having long conversations with friends and acquaintances.

———

And note that Franklin, who met Smith at least twice, never patented bifocal glasses, the lightening rod, nor the metal Franklin stove.

Today we can see examples of this in the CSA [Community Supported Agriculture] movement, which now has been, in some cases, expanded beyond vegetables to include milk, bakery goods, and soon, I hope, biofuels for energy.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.